Ology.com posted a recap of the 2nd episode of the American Idol Season Premiere.
In it, they write:
An Isaac Hanson lookalike (not a good thing) comes in and they tell him he looks like Steven. Then Steven tells him he looks Mick Jagger’s mouth. Steven seems to know a lot about Mick’s mouth… Anyway, the dude belts out a f*cking scary version of Lady Gaga’s “Bad Romance.” His facial expressions were like an orgasm coming to life. He croons, “I want your love” as he looks into Randy’s eyes. Creepster to the max.
I remember this guy auditioning (Gabriel Franks) and I do not remember thinking he looked like Isaac at all. Check out a photo of him in Access Hollywood’s American Idol Gallery and see what you think!