Secret: Back to the Island
| Image | Name | Description | How to Earn |
  |
Back to the Island 2017 Family Feud Winner | Be on the winning team for the Back to the Island 2017 Family Feud Game | Awarded to team who won 2017 Family Feud No Longer Available |
  |
Back to the Island 2017 Cards Against Humanity Game Winner | Be on the winning team for the Back to the Island 2017 Cards Against Humanity Game | Awarded to team who won 2017 Cards Against Humanity No Longer Available |
  |
Back to the Island 2018 Game Winner | Be on the winning team for the Back to the Island 2018 Game | Awarded to all teams for competing in Island Games 2018 No Longer Available |